Gold and Pt bar assay and payout question.

Gold Refining Forum

Help Support Gold Refining Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

lazersteve

Moderator
Staff member
Moderator
Joined
Feb 27, 2007
Messages
7,334
Location
Florida
Suppose I have a bar of gold and platinum mixed and you are a buyer and assayer of both.

I have a few questions:

1) How much do you charge to assay the bar for gold and platinum?

2) How long will this take from the time the bar arrives?

3) How much do you pay for each metal (Au & Pt) in percentage of spot?

4) How long before I see my total amount due?

5) Do you have any minimum quantities required?

6) Do you charge any other fees on the transaction?

7) Will another Au/Pt buyer honor your assay?

8) Will you honor another buyers assay of this material?

9) What are your turn around times on mixed Au & Pt that has previously been assayed.

10) What kind of certification/guarantee do I get with your assay.

Steve
 
Excellent post Steve, I have the same concerns with some metals I have ready to sell.

Best Regards
Rsuty
 
Thirty one views and one reply....

Are Rusty and I the only forum members willing to publically comment on the subject of the assaying, buying, and selling of fine Gold and Platinum? :shock:

Does anyone have any stories to share about your experinces with Platinum and Gold assayers and buyers: good, bad, or indifferent?

Steve
 
Hi Steve - from memory the refiner I have delt with in the past charged $150NZ for assay and $1NZ per gram of gold/platinum charge. Ten working day for results, with payment via electronic banking at the same time.

None of the other questions you mentioned were brought up. They will in future as I believe things were not quite above board.

Cheers

Deano
 
Steve I have no problems here in the UK and can get fast, accurate and cheap assays, two elements for around $50and a result in two days which is accepted by the local buyers.
Mixed gold platinum returns are around 95% Au and 90% Pt and I can trade palladium and rhodium at similar figures to the platinum.
 
lazersteve said:
1) How much do you charge to assay the bar for gold and platinum? $100

2) How long will this take from the time the bar arrives?. 1 day to 1 week, depending if I'm going to be making any money.

3) How much do you pay for each metal (Au & Pt) in percentage of spot?. 90%.

4) How long before I see my total amount due?. Same day of the assay.

5) Do you have any minimum quantities required?. 10 Oz.

6) Do you charge any other fees on the transaction? No.

7) Will another Au/Pt buyer honor your assay?. No.

8) Will you honor another buyers assay of this material?. No

9) What are your turn around times on mixed Au & Pt that has previously been assayed. 1 day-1week depending on amount or urgency.

10) What kind of certification/guarantee do I get with your assay. None.

Steve

Those are from a local small shop in Peru.
 
nickvc said:
Steve I have no problems here in the UK and can get fast, accurate and cheap assays, two elements for around $50and a result in two days which is accepted by the local buyers.
Mixed gold platinum returns are around 95% Au and 90% Pt and I can trade palladium and rhodium at similar figures to the platinum.


I wonder if these assays are honored by buyers in the states?

Ten percent seems a bit steep for 5+ oT lots of Pt.

Maybe I should make a trip to the UK and sell some Pt while I'm there :idea:

Steve
 
lazersteve said:
nickvc said:
Steve I have no problems here in the UK and can get fast, accurate and cheap assays, two elements for around $50and a result in two days which is accepted by the local buyers.
Mixed gold platinum returns are around 95% Au and 90% Pt and I can trade palladium and rhodium at similar figures to the platinum.


I wonder if these assays are honored by buyers in the states?

Ten percent seems a bit steep for 5+ oT lots of Pt.

Maybe I should make a trip to the UK and sell some Pt while I'm there :idea:

Steve

I already asked him to share who he is selling to, perhaps he would sate this publicly. As I would most certainly consider this as a viable option to selling locally.

Regards
Rusty
 
IMO you will always do better if you sell the gold and platinum separately and not in a mixed bar. I thought fournines had pretty good rates for both. What's the purpose of your question Steve?. You know all of this already. :?: :?: :shock:
It is generally hard to find final buyers for platinum, so everybody keeps their cards close to their chest, or accumulates for sales when a premium buyer appears. IMHO. So it is not uncommon to have buyers at 90% sellers at 105% of spot. Rhodium and Palladium are worse. It's just the way it is for small players like all of us.
 
HAuCl4 said:
IMO you will always do better if you sell the gold and platinum separately and not in a mixed bar. I thought fournines had pretty good rates for both. What's the purpose of your question Steve?. You know all of this already. :?: :?: :shock:
It is generally hard to find final buyers for platinum, so everybody keeps their cards close to their chest, or accumulates for sales when a premium buyer appears. IMHO. So it is not uncommon to have buyers at 90% sellers at 105% of spot. Rhodium and Palladium are worse. It's just the way it is for small players like all of us.

If Fournines (or others) would answer these questions here, then others and myself who don't already know the answers would know. I don't understand why buyers terms for buying gold are to the point and conversely why the same buyers terms for Pt are so convaluted.

Please explain to me the purpose of a two week delay in spot price locking when buying Pt?

Who's assay will Fournines honor on the Pt he buys?

Please note I'm only using Fournines in the questions above as you mentioned him as a buyer. If you are a Pt buyer feel free to substitute your name for his name for in the above.

Why do they buy small lots of Au at the drop of a hat, but require an act of congress to buy Pt.

Steve
 
lazersteve said:
Please note I'm only using Fournines in the questions above as you mentioned him as a buyer. If you are a Pt buyer feel free to substitute your name for his name for in the above.
Why do they buy small lots of Au at the drop of a hat, but require an act of congress to buy Pt.
Steve
I'm not actively a buyer or processor currently. What I do, I do for fun. If I can get Pt very cheap in small quantities, I buy it. I have always been irked by the same issues that you are. The market has always been like that for platinum products. My guess is due to the relatively low volume compared to gold and silver. It is always harder to sell Ferraris than Toyotas, and dealers have to be more careful.

I'll let fournines answer for himself if he wishes to do so. He probably has recently moved more platinum than all the the rest of the forum put together, except perhaps Lou.

If you need cash, platinum and rhodium are horrible inventories to have. But if you don't need cash, they can be the most profitable ones, once a buyer shows up. Just my 2c.
 
When the price of platinum was far greater than gold I could understand the Ferrari Toyota comparison, but with the two nearly equal in value, it seems outdated.

The other major point is what make one buyers assay any better than anothers. If I take my Pt bars to the local University and the professor and I run an ICP why is that not good enough? Furthermore if I alloy my refined gold with my refined Pt and the bar on XRF shoots 49.5% Au, 49.5% Pt, and 1% other, why pay on the gold immeadiately but not the Pt? If a bar shot 99.5% Au and 0.5% Pt would the buyer trust it?

Steve
 
I believe it is a matter of the volume in gold being easier to move than the small volumes in platinum, not an issue about prices. Just my opinion. On XRF's I prefer to pass and not have an opinion. It is very simple to separate the 2 metals, at least for you, and buyers like it simple or they charge more.
 
HAuCl4 said:
... It is very simple to separate the 2 metals, at least for you, and buyers like it simple or they charge more.

This statement only serves to make all the 'hoopla' surrounding selling refined Pt more unnecessary.

I'm looking for a buyer who, like when buying gold, has a set price they pay on the spot for Pt that can be confirmed of a reasonable purity. After a initial relationship is established, things should be much more comfortable for both parties. If an XRF reading of refined Pt can be off by 3%, then factor that into the price they will pay. All of the other extrenuating factors of the resale lot size, melt loss, etc. should also already be factored into the pricing schedule.

The major beef I have with sending 10+ ounces of Pt to any buyer is the large 'gray' area their Pt buying criteria creates. I would be very happy selling my Pt for 93% to a buyer who pays on the spot as opposed to getting 96-98% after several weeks of wondering what the buyer finally determines my Pt to be worth.

Furthermore, I have no problem getting my Pt assayed as long as the assay will be honored by other buyers.

Steve
 
lazersteve said:
Suppose I have a bar of gold and platinum mixed and you are a buyer and assayer of both.

I have a few questions:

1) How much do you charge to assay the bar for gold and platinum? Depends on to where you send it, the melt and assay fee can be $150-400 depending on who you deal with, or it can be free. Again, it is contingent upon the nature of the sample, not all things are as easily analyzed, but bars are a good start!

2) How long will this take from the time the bar arrives? Depends on when your material arrived and its place in the queue with other customers' lots. If all the equipment is working well, it can be the same day or several days later.

3) How much do you pay for each metal (Au & Pt) in percentage of spot? Depends on the quantity and the quality of the sample. If you send in a material that is exclusively gold and platinum, then there is less chemical work required so you can expect a higher price.

4) How long before I see my total amount due? Depends on if you want XRF or ICP-AES to settle on; XRF samples can usually be prepared in a day (bear in mind that you're sampling platinum, not gold and it's a whole different animal). ICP-AES takes longer as the sample must be digested, ultra filtered, diluted quantitatively etc.

5) Do you have any minimum quantities required? Most people do. Look at JM or other large refiner's lot treatment fees and deductions which are designed to weed out all but the most worthwhile of refining contracts. It's simply not worth the time to buy 10 grams of platinum and have the customer demand a free ICP or even XRF and still pay even 95%. It is not profitable to do and maintain rates that large clients get.

6) Do you charge any other fees on the transaction? Not necessarily, but if it is a low profit transaction, then possibly. If it costs $15 to wire the payment, and the profit is only $80 on an ounce of Pt, then I would charge a wire fee. I don't always do that, but it is not unreasonable that I maintain the profit I desire while rendering a fair service. In any case, whomever I purchase material from will be advised of that possibility, if their lot is that small.

7) Will another Au/Pt buyer honor your assay? That is up to the other buyer and out of my hands.

8) Will you honor another buyers assay of this material? Depends upon the buyer. If it is RMC, Heraeus, JM, Metalor's, and a few others, then yes but with certain reservations.

9) What are your turn around times on mixed Au & Pt that has previously been assayed. This question is entirely dependent on how well I trust the other assay and how long I think I'll be out my own money.

10) What kind of certification/guarantee do I get with your assay. That I will honor it when I purchase the material.

Steve


If I have a client come to me with an assay from a reputable assayer and his material is commercially pure and in a marketable form, then it's a different story than buying scrap material. I even got into trouble recently with a large Pt trading firm over old yet SEALED platinum sponge from Engelhard. I know it doesn't have a shelf-life, but they weren't buying it. If I don't have to refine it, and all I have to do is assay it and pass it on with the next bunch, then I'm willing to pay higher, but my assay must be ICP-AES and it's not going to be same day, and possibly not even the same week. All Pt that goes on to end market users or to the exchanges is assayed in that fashion.

Small quantities of relatively pure Pt, I think 90-94% is plenty fair. Large quantities, I think 95-97,5% is more than fair. That's with no fees, no sampling charge, no lot treatment, no 1/4 ozt deductions. But that's just what I'm willing to pay, based on what I know I have to do. Break down the refining terms from Heraeus or JM and see what it comes to; I have the current schedules at hand. You may see 99%+ on Pt but there's a variable price per ounce processed, lot treatment minimums, then there's the fact that they don't pay you in full for six to twelve weeks (usually a 90% advance with 5-6% interest) and God help you if some cadmium or TSCA-controlled substance sneaks in the refining lot! Long story made short enough, by the time you wade through all the different fees and charges, you're not winning unless you send in hundreds of ounces at a time and witness it yourself.

Let's take Steve's 2 ozt troy bar as a working example.
If he sends it in, I must weigh it, melt it, sample it, XRF it (which I do not really trust at parts per ten thousand precision, especially at the confidence interval requisite to insure that I can not refine it and just batch it with the rest), and if it isn't commercially pure, then I have to roll it, anneal it, roll it, then digest it for several days, filter, rinse, hydrolytically separate it, then reduce, then go after the residual Pt in the waste effluent, which I won't recover for some time. Sounds pretty easy? It's not. It's not as simple as just dropping three times with ammonium chloride (that would take too long for one, although it might get the job done). Now I know Steve to be a meticulous, competent, chemist who wouldn't send something out unless it were a slam dunk, but how am I supposed to trust just any person's "pure platinum powder"? On large lots, it's getting refined. I'm willing to hedge it on preliminary assays at the bottom of the RSD.

Also, people forget that gold is much more cut and dried than Pt, Pd, and Rh. There's much more of a market for gold. It's much easier to sell for a profitable price. It's also just easier to refine.

And, if people with small quantities of Pt haven't figured out yet, the PGM market is basically a cartel run by traders at a select few large firms. All others tow the line.

Another thing to consider is that an XRF reading can be off by 3% for numerous reasons:

1. It's off calibration or just running on an algorithm. The more you use it, the sooner you lose it.
2. It's a handheld, low-power unit that has minimal penetrative capability, especially given how dense platinum is. A 30 second acquisition time is usually not sufficient except on kW power units.
3. You're reading a powder.
4. You're reading a liquid.
5. You're measuring a button that was melted in a contaminated dish and it's contaminated on the bottom, and/or the top.
6. You're measuring a button that has Pt congeners like Ni and Co and Fe, all of which may phase separate in the Pt and not form a homogeneous alloy.
7. You're measuring a button that was torch melted and thus exacerbating problem reason 6--it's not homogenous as it was not stirred and possibly not even melted all the way through.

The fairest shake I can give anyone is to digest the stuff and run it as a refining lot. Unfortunately, that is not always practical for long refining schedule metals like Rh and Ir, but it is for Pd and Pt.


Steve,

I'll gladly buy your triple refined Pt for 93% of spot, the day I receive it. You'll have the wire that very day. I will buy it as if it were 99.9% Pt if you yourself warrant that you refined all of it three times. If you want to send out for 3rd party assay, be my guest. If it turns out that it's commercially pure, I'll make a substantially higher offer. Just remember that a good multielement assay starts at $400.
 
Great post Lou. Thank you for that.

It's a real eye opener to the PGM trading world.
 
I forgot to add:

the melt loss is negligible on solid material.

Truth be told, melt loss is only common with sponge and most particularly blacks because they have a high surface area and have much adsorbed water and often hydrogen on their surface. It is a particular problem with palladium. Melt loss on Pd black is at most 3%, on Pt black less, and on the sponges, almost always between 0.1-0.4%. It will go toward the low end by firing it in a quartz dish at about 1000 C for an hour. This is not to be done with Pd, as it will oxidize if exposed to the atmosphere.

The weeks involved in selling it is typically due to one of two things:

1. You sold to a consolidator, which almost every single refiner in the U.S. is for PGMs with the exception of about a half dozen; of those half dozen, there are only two full service (all PGM refined in house) in North America. One of them is Inco.

2. You managed to get enough together to sell to an actual refiner, not a broker which sells to them and they will take their time to refine it. They will also sell your metal and use the profits for a few weeks to make even more money.
 
Lou: Your knowledge of PGM commercial dealing and chemistry is pretty much complete!. (better than mine anyways). It's a racket at the top. :lol:
 
Back
Top