ChatGPT seemed to think my sodium thiosulfate theory is plausible, below is a summary of conclusions from the discussion. (Disclaimer: ChatGPT is far from infallible, this is just intended as a conversation starter when OP engages with a professional advisory chemist.)
Chemical A is most likely sodium hydroxide (NaOH).
Chemical B is likely sodium sulfide (Na
2S) or sodium polysulfide (Na
2S
x), with lead either as a contaminant or part of a stabilizer.
Chemical C could be sodium hydrosulfide (NaHS) or elemental sulfur (S
8).
The trace elements observed in the XRF readings may be explained if they were sourced from naturally occurring mineral deposits, geothermal brines, or evaporites. For example, lead, copper, and iron in Chemical B suggest it may come from sulfide ores or industrial byproducts rather than being a highly purified reagent. Sodium, chlorine, and sulfur in Chemical C suggest it could be derived from natural sulfur deposits or geothermal brines. Trace elements like magnesium, aluminum, silicon, calcium, zirconium, and molybdenum are commonly found in natural mineral formations and brine deposits. However, if the chemicals were synthetically manufactured, the impurities could come from raw materials, industrial processing methods, or contamination during storage and handling.
If chemical B is sodium sulfide (Na
2S), it reacts with sodium hydroxide to form sodium thiosulfate in the following reaction:
2NaOH + Na
2S + S → Na
2S
2O
3 + H
2O
If chemical B is sodium polysulfide (Na
2S
x), the reaction can be written as:
NaOH + Na
2S
x + (x−2)S → Na
2S
2O
3 + Na
2S
x−2
Gold is then dissolved into solution through complexation with thiosulfate, forming a stable gold-thiosulfate complex according to the equation:
4Au + 8Na
2S
2O
3 + O
2 + 2H
2O → 4Na
3[Au(S
2O
3)
2] + 4NaOH
Gold is precipitated from the thiosulfate solution by reducing Au
3+ to metallic gold in fine black particles. During this process, thiosulfate (S
2O
32-) converts to sulfite (SO
32-) as a byproduct, and the reaction proceeds as follows:
2[Au(S
2O
3)
2]
3− + 6NaOH + 3Na
2S → 2Au
0 + 3Na
2S
2O
3 + 3Na
2SO
3 + 3H
2O
If excess sulfide is present, gold can precipitate as gold sulfide (Au
2S
3), which is also black. In this case, the reaction follows:
2[Au(S
2O
3)
2]
3− + 3Na
2S + 6NaOH → Au
2S
3↓ + 6Na
2S
2O
3 + 3H
2O
Sodium sulfide (Na
2S) is the preferred precipitant for metallic gold (Au
0) recovery, while sodium hydrosulfide (NaHS) may favor gold sulfide (Au
2S
3) formation.
Maintaining the proper pH is crucial to the process. A pH range of 9 to 10 is optimal for the stability of gold-thiosulfate complexes. If the pH drops below 8.5, thiosulfate becomes unstable and begins to decompose, primarily forming elemental sulfur (S) and sulfur dioxide (SO
2). In the presence of excess sulfide (S
2−) or under certain conditions, toxic hydrogen sulfide (H
2S) gas may also be released. If the pH rises above 10.5, gold remains in solution, reducing precipitation efficiency. To avoid these issues, sodium hydroxide should be added gradually while monitoring pH with a meter rather than relying on pH strips.
To recover any remaining gold in solution, zinc dust is added to reduce the gold-thiosulfate complex back to metallic gold. The reaction follows:
2[Au(S
2O
3)
2]
3− + 3Zn → 2Au + 3ZnS
2O
3
This reaction takes five to six hours, after which the solution is allowed to settle for one to two hours before filtering. The pH should be maintained between 8 and 9 for efficient gold reduction.
One of the main hazards in this process is the potential release of hydrogen sulfide gas (H
2S), which is highly toxic and fatal at concentrations of 1000 ppm. Even at low concentrations (as low as 10-20 ppm), it can cause irritation, and at 100-200 ppm, it can lead to serious health effects. To mitigate this danger, the chemicals should be kept away from acids and moisture, and hydrogen sulfide detectors and proper ventilation should be in place.
Impurities such as lead, copper, and iron sulfides may co-precipitate with gold, reducing its purity. This can be addressed by pretreating the solution with EDTA, a chelating agent, to remove base metals before gold precipitation. Controlled aeration can help oxidize unwanted sulfide impurities before gold is precipitated. After precipitation, the black gold powder should be thoroughly washed with hot dilute ammonium thiosulfate to remove excess sulfides and improve purity.
This process requires careful pH control, proper handling of sulfide chemicals, and strict safety precautions to minimize the risks associated with hydrogen sulfide gas.
The disposal of thiosulfate-containing solutions should be done carefully. Thiosulfate can degrade into sulfate and sulfite, which are less hazardous, but the presence of residual sulfide and heavy metals may require neutralization or filtration before disposal.
While zinc is a common choice for gold recovery, other reducing agents such as iron (Fe) or sodium borohydride (NaBH
4) could also be explored depending on cost, availability, and process efficiency. Iron could be used in the form of steel wool, in a process which involves both chemical reduction and adsorption, where the gold particles adhere to the steel surface. In this case, the formula for reduction follows:
2[Au(S
2O
3)
2]
3− + 3Fe → 2Au + 3Fe(S
2O
3)
2
The adsorption effect can enhance recovery efficiency by capturing fine gold particles that might otherwise remain in solution. Once gold is deposited onto the steel wool, it needs to be separated, typically by burning the steel wool in a controlled environment, leaving behind a gold-rich residue that can be further refined by smelting or acid digestion.
Steel wool was favored for cementation of gold from thiosulfate solutions by the infamous Dr Poe, as discussed on page 3 of this fascinating thread:
https://goldrefiningforum.com/threads/thiosulphate-dropped-testing-for-pm.12284/
I asked ChatGPT to produce instructions for performing the process; the response was as follows:
Gold Recovery Using the Thiosulfate Process: Step-by-Step Instructions
Safety Precautions
- Work in a well-ventilated area or a fume hood.
- Wear personal protective equipment (PPE), including gloves, safety goggles, and a respirator rated for hydrogen sulfide (H₂S) gas.
- Keep acids away from sulfide-containing solutions to prevent toxic H₂S gas release.
- Monitor pH levels carefully to avoid decomposition of thiosulfate and unwanted side reactions.
- Have emergency equipment (neutralizing agents, spill kits, and an H₂S detector) readily available.
Materials and Equipment
Chemicals Required
- Sodium hydroxide (NaOH)
- Sodium sulfide (Na₂S) or sodium polysulfide (Na₂Sₓ)
- Sulfur (S₈) (if using sodium polysulfide)
- Thiosulfate source (Na₂S₂O₃) (may form in situ)
- Zinc dust (Zn) or steel wool (Fe) for gold precipitation
- EDTA (optional, for removing base metals)
- Distilled water
Equipment Needed
- Glass or plastic reaction vessel (no metal containers)
- pH meter (preferred) or high-precision pH strips
- Magnetic stirrer or mechanical stirrer
- Filtration system (Büchner funnel with vacuum, or fine mesh filter paper)
- Drying oven or heat lamp (optional, for drying gold powder)
Procedure
1. Preparation of the Leaching Solution
- Dissolve sodium hydroxide (NaOH) in distilled water to create a 10% NaOH solution. Stir until fully dissolved.
- If using sodium sulfide (Na₂S):
- Slowly add Na₂S to the NaOH solution while stirring.
- If necessary, adjust pH to 9–10 using additional NaOH.
- If using sodium polysulfide (Na₂Sₓ):
- Add elemental sulfur (S₈) to Na₂S in NaOH solution. Stir continuously until sulfur dissolves.
- Maintain a temperature of 40–50°C to speed up dissolution.
- Adjust pH to 9–10.
2. Leaching Gold into Solution
- Add gold-bearing material to the solution.
- Stir continuously while maintaining a pH of 9–10. Monitor and adjust with NaOH as needed.
- Allow the reaction to proceed for 12–24 hours, ensuring oxygen is present to facilitate gold dissolution:4Au+8Na2S2O3+O2+2H2O→4Na3[Au(S2O3)2]+4NaOH4Au + 8Na₂S₂O₃ + O₂ + 2H₂O → 4Na₃[Au(S₂O₃)₂] + 4NaOH4Au+8Na2S2O3+O2+2H2O→4Na3[Au(S2O3)2]+4NaOH
- Periodically check for the presence of gold in solution using a test reagent (e.g., stannous chloride).
3. Precipitation of Gold
- Filter out any remaining solids to obtain a clear gold-thiosulfate solution.
- If necessary, pretreat with EDTA to chelate base metals.
- Precipitate gold using either:
a) Zinc Dust Method
- Add zinc dust while stirring.
- Allow the reaction to proceed for 5–6 hours:2[Au(S2O3)2]3−+3Zn→2Au+3ZnS2O32[Au(S₂O₃)₂]³⁻ + 3Zn → 2Au + 3ZnS₂O₃2[Au(S2O3)2]3−+3Zn→2Au+3ZnS2O3
- Let the precipitated gold settle for 1–2 hours.
b) Steel Wool (Iron) Method
- Add steel wool directly into the solution.
- Stir gently for even exposure.
- Gold will adsorb onto the steel surface while iron dissolves:2[Au(S2O3)2]3−+3Fe→2Au+3Fe(S2O3)22[Au(S₂O₃)₂]³⁻ + 3Fe → 2Au + 3Fe(S₂O₃)₂2[Au(S2O3)2]3−+3Fe→2Au+3Fe(S2O3)2
- Once deposition is complete, remove the steel wool and burn it in a controlled environment to recover gold residue.
4. Filtration and Washing
- Filter the gold precipitate using fine mesh filter paper or a vacuum filtration system.
- Wash the precipitate thoroughly with hot distilled water to remove residual thiosulfate.
- Optionally, rinse with a hot, dilute ammonium thiosulfate solution to improve purity.
5. Drying and Refining
- Dry the precipitate under mild heat using an oven (50–70°C) or a heat lamp.
- The dried gold can be smelted or refined using aqua regia for higher purity.
Disposal Considerations
- Neutralization of Waste Solution
- Gradually add hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂) to oxidize sulfides and reduce toxicity.
- Adjust pH to 7–8 using NaOH or sulfuric acid as needed.
- Filtration of Heavy Metals
- Precipitate heavy metals by adding calcium hydroxide (Ca(OH)₂) or ferric sulfate (Fe₂(SO₄)₃).
- Filter the solids and dispose of according to local environmental regulations.
- Final Disposal
- Ensure that no toxic sulfide compounds remain before discarding.
Conclusion
This method allows for the extraction and recovery of gold with high efficiency while minimizing environmental impact. Proper pH control and safety measures are critical to preventing unwanted side reactions and ensuring worker safety.