g_axelsson said:
I would express myself a bit different for the general situation.
Boiling is okay when you don't have any dissolved values in your liquid. Who cares if they loose some iron chloride. The raised heat and constant agitation of the boiling is a good thing when dissolving base metals.
Boiling should never be used if you have values dissolved in the liquid. Some of it would be carried away on the mist produced by the bursting bubbles.
Göran
While I agree with you in principal, I don't agree in practice. With values in solution, I used boiling extensively, but I did so with a watch glass in place. In fact, I insisted on boiling my silver nitrate solution when it was prepared as electrolyte for my silver cell. The boiling aciton drove out traces of those familiar brown fumes with which we are all familiar. That shifted the color of my electrolyte such that I could determine that there was no copper in my silver. I also drove my gold chloride to the state of boiling at the end of the dissolution process, which readily disclosed if I had a lack of nitric or HCl. One observed the formation of the familiar brown cloud, or lack thereof.
You can witness the results of the use of a watch glass by watching the (colored) solution coalesce on the bottom side of the watch glass, then drip back in to the vessel. You can also verify that you aren't losing values by condensing traces of vapors escaping from the vessel, using a porcelain spatula, then testing with stannous chloride. I found the values weren't contained in the vapors, but were being propelled from the solution by rapid boiling.
Boiling can be an important part of the refining process. Just avoid doing so when your intended purpose is to EVAPORATE. That should be accomplished at a rate below a boil, to avoid the loss of values from particles evacuating the vessel under high energy.
If you mean evaporate, that's exactly what you should say. If boiling is mentioned, the wrong message is sent, so we start all over again correcting misinformation.
If, somewhere in Hoke, there is mention of boil when she means evaporate, the error should be corrected.
I do not claim to be right---or wrong. I'm simply reporting on my method of operation, which was successful, and hard won. I evaporated a solution too quickly once (I boiled lightly) and ended up with the side of my travel trailer covered in purple stain. This was very early in my learning curve, and long before I had a fume hood. I was exhausting with a fan in the window. Never again did that happen to me. A fume hood was my next project.
Harold