Besides having to destroy the film, if you don't cut the film up in some way, the full sheets will stick together and it will take forever (many hours, in some cases - sometimes, the full sheets never completely strip) for the solution to penetrate between the sheets, even with tumbling. When the emulsion gets wet, it gets sticky. You can run the sheets one at a time but, of course, that's a very slow process.
Occasionally, we received film that had once gotten wet and then had dried. The sheets were permanently glued together, some in 20 pound chunks that were way too thick to run through the chopper. When you tried to pull the sheets apart, they tore. The only way to process it was incineration, which can lose as much as 30% of the silver in the smoke.
A paper shredder works but it twists the pieces badly and this gives the material a very low bulk density. In other words, very little weight of material will fit into a given container. Hammer mills do the same thing. Equipment that actual cuts (chops or shears) the film into small flat pieces works much better, but it is expensive.
We chopped the film into about 3/8" pieces and put it into 40 gal fiber drums, which held about 65 pounds of this material. Occasionally, someone would send in material that that had been run through a hammer mill or a paper shredder. The drums would only hold about 10 pounds of this material. Therefore, in a given sized container, you can run about 6 times more production with chopped film than you can with film run though a paper shredder.