Many times it is practically impossible to judge what a metal is by looking at it or its color, sometimes we can determine what a metal is with a magnet, density, its hardness, how it reacts to a grinding wheel, how soft it is, how it melts, how it reacts to a flame or blow pipe test, and how it reacts to acids or chemicals...
But, even these methods it can be hard to tell, the only way to be sure is by testing it.
If its silver try schwerters solution if you would get get a blood red reaction for silver, if not then you could file off some metal dissolve it as a chloride and test with stannous chloride.