HCL+Clorox ratio, conflicting numbers

Gold Refining Forum

Help Support Gold Refining Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
variable,
That was so many questions at once I do not think I could answer them all, if you have many questions you should spend more time studying and doing small experiments.

I will not try to answer the questions, but I will try to get you to see something I see.

HCl will not dissolve gold; gold is far below hydrogen in the reactivity series of metals, HCl in not a strong enough oxidizer to dissolve gold. Nitric acid can oxidize gold, or chlorine gas can oxidize gold (pry away an electron from gold’s atom).

Sodium hypochlorite (Bleach) is an alkali solution; the sodium hydroxide NaOH involved in the bleach keeps it caustic enough to keep the chlorine in the solution of water.

When you mix the HCl acid with the Alkali Bleach you form chlorine gas which can oxidize gold in solution, but we also lower the acidity of our acid with every addition of bleach forming salt out of our acid (HCl + NaOH --> NaCl + H2O), also the chlorine is a gas that wants to bubble out of solution, so we can here where too much bleach at once can destroy our HCl, and make table salt, and waste chlorine as gas, also the lower the acidity the easier the chlorine would stay in solution, temperature also plays a major role in how the chlorine stays in solution.

So when we have gold fine powder or foils (this method has a very hard time trying to dissolve solid bigger pieces of metal), the gold in the HCl is oxidized by the chlorine gas (formed from the acid and bleach), this chlorine take’s electrons from the gold atoms, the gold becomes an ion (Cation), this gold Cation joins with three chloride (Anions) to form a soluble salt or compound of gold chloride, or dissolved gold in solution.

Now we already discussed loss of chlorine gas through gassing out of solution, and of our acid being neutralized, by the alkali solution, so we need to be aware we need free HCl acid in solution, and just enough chlorine gas to do the job, we can add a little more bleach a little at a time to keep the reaction going.

I believe far too often when we begin learning, recovery and refining, that a newbie’s we tend to way over use acids and solutions, we are impatient, and want to see something happen now, or we do not give it time to react, and do not know how much to add or what the reaction would even look like, much of our solutions or acids and reagents are wasted, and we create other problems for ourselves by using too much.

I would add the gold to the acid, and add the sodium hypochlorite just a little at a time, (personally, I prefer a warm solution), give it time, the reaction may not be very visible maybe only a few tiny bubbles.

Points to consider we want our solution acidic (bleach raises pH), so we must have enough acid to keep it acidic, also adding too much bleach to fast just gasses off most of the chlorine before it has time to react with the gold (also making salt out of our acid), to high of a temperature will also gas off our chlorine faster, but also too low of a temperature take so much longer for the reaction to occur and dissolve our gold, overuse of bleach can leave oxidizer in our solution when we go to precipitate the gold, I believe many times members have also used so much sodium hypochlorite the may have also raised the pH very close to neutral (mainly just dissolved salts, not much free HCl acid to help drive off chlorine), in this case they may have to evaporate the solution much farther than they normally would have to (until the acid concentrates enough to drive off the chlorine in this solution), at this point they may have salts forming from the solution becoming so saturated with salt, a little acid may help in this case.

Now so not only will gold use up your acid in the reaction but the NaClO can also use the acid up, it would be interesting to know what the pH of some of these guys solutions are, that are having trouble with too much chlorine left in solution before they precipitate (my guess is they may have no free HCl and they may not have a very acid solution left to drive off chlorine easily.

When I use HCl/NaClO I do not follow a certain ratio, but if I did I would look at what was recommended, and use that as a guide only, I would still have plenty of HCl and add the bleach on a small proportion at a time, (using the ratio as a guide to help to understand when I may be adding more than needed), but also I am not suggesting others do it this way.
 
Also, I think you might have mis-read what Steve typed. I'm pretty sure he said that if all of the gold was dissolved after the first addition of bleach, do not add any more. Basically, you need to use however much you need to use, but just don't think add any extra if you don't need to.

Question for Butcher, do you really re-type those types of responses (your last one here above)? Or do you have a notepad/txt document that you just copy and paste it into the forum? I've seen you type that information so many times, if you are really uniquely typing it each time, !!! Good for you! You have more patience then most!!! :)

-Ken
 
Yes! Steve did say if the gold is dissolved than stop - I've misread it. But, than again, we don't want to go over the limit if it's not. Thanks for the time answering my questions + so quickly. I think i'll give my HCl + Bleach solution more time next time since it attacks surface of gold particles somewhat slower than AR with smaller Bleach additions. Probably, this way I won't overdo it. I think I understand the process. That is, if there is alot of Cl gas in the lab area it's not where it's suppose to be since it needs to be in the solution to get the work done and not out of it.
 
Yes I guess I do repeat the same old thing, yes I do type them every time, I never had a memory, so I really do not remember what I said before, and really would not know where it was to be able to copy and past it, I guess every one of us answer the same old questions over and over, and people keep asking the same old questions over and over, maybe that is not a bad idea, I have been told lately I keep answering the same old questions spending too much time typing, so I suppose from now on I should just copy and paste my answers.

Read Hokes book and study the forum.
Read Hokes book and study the forum.
Read Hokes book and study the forum.
Read Hokes book and study the forum.
Read Hokes book and study the forum.
Read Hokes book and study the forum.

Wow that is much simpler, and a member would have all of his questions answered.

Read Hokes book and study the forum.
 
It is also possible to put gold into solution as a chloride using bleach (NaClO) without using HCl. Bring the pH of the bleach down to just above neutral by small additions of HCl or even acetic acid (vinegar). This will make hypochlorous acid (HOCl). To this, add sodium or calcium chloride to make chloride available for the reaction. This solution, plus whatever material you wish to put into solution, must be placed into an airtight container with ALL air excluded and then agitated or rotated to maintain maximum exposure.

The reason for excluding air is that hypochlorous acid (HOCl) is very unstable and, without backpressure on it, it will lose its oxygen atom to the air and become HCl, instead of becoming part of the dissolution of gold process.
 
Butcher, So just to be clear, what I should do is : [b]Read Hokes book and study the forum.[/b]?
What a novel concept! I am going to try to Read Hokes book and study the forum.
Thanks for all you do, I love this site, and am starting to really like this hobby. I am at the point of (almost) getting ready for my first melt down of collected powders from multiple small scale processes.
I expect about .75 to 1 grams, stuff is still wet right now so I am not sure. Wish me luck.
Thanks again, oh and : Read Hokes book and study the forum.
 
mrsanders02,
I do wish you luck, but since your doing your homework, it is not as much about luck. as it having an understanding of what you are doing, that and a little practice with what your learning, I think you will do just fine, at least you are on the right track towards success.

I do not like working with very small batches, if I do I will normally save the powders from the small batches up until I have more to work with, seems like a little gold is left behind here and there (recovered later), this is more noticeable on many very small volumes than it is on one larger batch.
 
As Butcher and others have said, I don't use a fixed "ratio" of acid/bleach. I cover the gold in acid then add bleach "to taste" until it's all dissolved.
 
try this web page :

http://www.ehow.com/how_10075085_leach-gold-ore-chlorination.html

it says 15% bleach (sodium Hypo chlorate) 33% Hydrochloric Acid 52% water and add enough to cover your ore. and to use an ORP meter to maintain 1,000 mv and to not go lower than 400 mv the reaction is complete when the voltage does not change when you add more HCl but read the webpage it has a moderate detail about the only thing missing is the temperature of the hot water
the page can tell you better than i can

http://www.ehow.com/how_10075085_leach-gold-ore-chlorination.html
 
Don in Mindanao said:
try this web page :

http://www.ehow.com/how_10075085_leach-gold-ore-chlorination.html

it says 15% bleach (sodium Hypo chlorate) 33% Hydrochloric Acid 52% water and add enough to cover your ore. and to use an ORP meter to maintain 1,000 mv and to not go lower than 400 mv the reaction is complete when the voltage does not change when you add more HCl but read the webpage it has a moderate detail about the only thing missing is the temperature of the hot water
the page can tell you better than i can

http://www.ehow.com/how_10075085_leach-gold-ore-chlorination.html

Don I am not sure if you did read all the post on this subject but I am sure you have the best intentions by giving this link, however all the information needed is here on the forum and at the forum you will know that it is correct, if not a moderator will make sure that people will not make mistakes and correct the problem.

If you send people to other places you should be sure that the information you give is correct.
and when you quote you should also make sure it is 100 % correct, we are working with chemicals and small mistakes can be dangerous, some people are lazy and do not read everything. They just skim pages and then make a mess.

you write 15 % bleach ( Sodium Hypo chlorate ) the website writes (sodium hypochlorite)
You write 33 % Hydrochloric Acid webside writes 33 % hydrochloric acid
you write 52 % water the website writes nothing about water in point 3 Rebecca smith writes that you should put the ORP meter in the water mixture
now I know that Rebecca Smith ( the one that wrote the article is a specialist in greenhouses and home decor ) but she never write anywhere to ad water , so my question is do I ad water first, do I pour the water in the acid, do I pour the bleach first then the acid and the water . Ok I am sure you get my point.
My next question is, can you explain the difference between Sodium Metabisulphate and Sodium Metabisulphite.

On the same website there are other instructions for the same process that will mix Bleach and HCL in another mixture that would make me worried
I would therefor not link to another place is i would not be sure it would not harm or mis inform people.

last but not least welcome to the forum, do use the search and try to find Hoke book it is a very good book for beginners and take the guided tour

squarecoinman
 
I agree, not only would that not work it is very dangerous, Rebecca has read something somewhere that she has no clue about, trying to repeat that information she is giving people misinformation, that not only, would not recover any gold out of the rock, it could actually kill somebody who tried to follow the instructions, or the procedure as written, the waste treatment procedure can also harm others.
 
"It is also possible to put gold into solution as a chloride using bleach (NaClO) without using HCl. Bring the pH of the bleach down to just above neutral by small additions of HCl or even acetic acid (vinegar). This will make hypochlorous acid (HOCl). To this, add sodium or calcium chloride to make chloride available for the reaction. This solution, plus whatever material you wish to put into solution, must be placed into an airtight container with ALL air excluded and then agitated or rotated to maintain maximum exposure.

The reason for excluding air is that hypochlorous acid (HOCl) is very unstable and, without backpressure on it, it will lose its oxygen atom to the air and become HCl, instead of becoming part of the dissolution of gold process."



There are none so blind, as those who will not see.
 
Traveller11 said:
It is also possible to put gold into solution as a chloride using bleach (NaClO) without using HCl. Bring the pH of the bleach down to just above neutral by small additions of HCl or even acetic acid (vinegar). This will make hypochlorous acid (HOCl). To this, add sodium or calcium chloride to make chloride available for the reaction. This solution, plus whatever material you wish to put into solution, must be placed into an airtight container with ALL air excluded and then agitated or rotated to maintain maximum exposure.

The reason for excluding air is that hypochlorous acid (HOCl) is very unstable and, without backpressure on it, it will lose its oxygen atom to the air and become HCl, instead of becoming part of the dissolution of gold process.

Would this work?
 
Yes gold can be put into solution as described, what Traveller11 is discussing is a basic (opposite of acidic) hypochlorite leaching system used to put gold into solution with some types of (normally pretreated) ore. It is not normally used for materials like electronic scrap, or other metal industrial scrap materials. Where other processes are known to work better.
 
butcher said:
...
Sodium hypochlorite (Bleach) is an alkali solution; the sodium hydroxide NaOH involved in the bleach keeps it caustic enough to keep the chlorine in the solution of water.
...
I found this post exciting, because it's the first time I saw someone mention NaOH and that it's actually ok. For ages I've been trying to find out what's in "Chlorox". We don't have it in Australia. So I wanted to compare our "White King", which also has NaOH in it that had been concerning me. (The idea of mixing acid and alkaline sounds like how people hurt themselves.) Now, a search for MSDS gave up about 20 Chlorox bleach products! Would this be the one you guys use? It's "Regular Bleach". http://www.thecloroxcompany.com/downloads/msds/bleach/cloroxregularbleach0809_.pdf

White King has 42g/l sodium hypochlorite: available chlorine 4% when packed, with an estimate of dropping to 2% available chlorine by the Use By date. It also has 9g/l sodium hydroxide. So it sounds similar. What's written on your Chlorox bottles?

Also, and just thinking out loud here, it makes sense to me to keep a not too tight lid on the HCl/NaOCl combo, in that you would need less HCl overall. By my reckoning, a gaseous chlorine jar-cloud should help keep more Cl in solution longer than if it were open to the air. So since the Cl evaporates but the NaOH doesn't, you'd eventually run out of the total amount of bleach you can put in, even small amounts at a time, before the acid becomes neutralised and you need more acid. Correct me if I have it wrong.

[Edit: By "not too tight lid", I meant the first bite or so of the thread; the lid still rattling around. Just to keep the chlorine gas concentration up but definitely no pressure build-up. Perhaps "loose fitting cling wrap" would be a suitable choice.]
 
butcher said:
Yes gold can be put into solution as described, what Traveller11 is discussing is a basic (opposite of acidic) hypochlorite leaching system used to put gold into solution with some types of (normally pretreated) ore. It is not normally used for materials like electronic scrap, or other metal industrial scrap materials. Where other processes are known to work better.
Thanks for the information.
 
Someone else here on the forum can explain this better than I can, I am not so good at putting thoughts to words, and often say things backwards from the way I think, and here I may have added thoughts on two processes somewhat together to try and get these thoughts across...

Normally on the forum in the process where we use HCl acid with our fine gold powders or foils we add plenty of acid for the amount of gold, an excess HCl will not be a problem, and excess acid is actually more desirable than not having enough, for several reasons (one is to stay acidic), we also add just a little bleach at a time in small proportions, adding (the about a 3% to 6% solution of sodium hypochlorite NaClO), the normal household bleach used to wash your clothes, not the new lemon smelly types or some other fancy kind, (the Clorox is one name brand bleach), or sodium hypochlorite, the sodium hypochlorite is added in small proportions at a time to keep chlorine forming in solution and reacting with our gold (allowing reaction time in between additions with keeping temperature in mind), until the gold is dissolved.
Here we need to be careful not too add too much NaClO bleach, for several reasons, besides just wasting our money on chemicals, we dilute the solution, we lower the pH, making salt NaCl out of our acid, we can have excess chlorine (or hypochlorite if we go too basic) which can make recovery of the gold more difficult later, or until we remove the excess chlorine from solution before the precipitation stage, ( or if made basic we acidify to convert excess HOCl to chlorine, and then drive off the dissolved excess chlorine gas from solution) usually done with sunlight and time, or slightly heating the solution…

Just a note: heat will drive off gases; dissolved gases stay easier in a cold solution than a hot one. Pressure can also hold gases in a cold solution easier, but can become very dangerous, pressurizing a solution can also increase the temperature, or lower the boiling point of the solution, pressure and heat can force out gases easier (or more deeply, for lack of a better word here), and actually push more dissolved gases out of solution further, than the same solution at a lower pressure and temperature.
But here we are working with acids or dangerous solutions, where adding pressure to the equation can easily get us hurt if we do not understand the process or how it would be done properly and safely.

As a boiler man, I can safely heat water to drive out more oxygen from water under pressure, in a pressurized heated vessel (with all of the safety’s included in this pressurized vessel), and understanding the principles involved in the thermodynamic reactions.
But with acids an these chemical reactions taking place, and the gases that form here in these reactions, there is no way I would try this in my lab, without a whole lot more understanding of how to do it safely, and understanding what type of vessel, an understanding of what type of safety devices would be needed, understanding of the temperature pressure relationship of the acid solutions, and of the gases that were produced...
Basically I have just enough knowledge to keep myself out of danger here and know I should not try it, and I also know, or understand that there is no reason to try it anyway...


In this process the HCl acid and sodium hypochlorite form chlorine gas in solution, which becomes the oxidizer for our gold, taking electrons from the gold atom, which then the gold ions can form a bond with the reduced acid and chlorine (chlorides) to put the gold into an ionic solution or dissolved salt of gold chloride dissolved in solution (along with NaCl) normally still in excess of HCl acid ad water (we arent considiring other possible base metals here)...

Normally there is no reason to try and pressurize this, as HCl and sodium hypochlorite are cheap, adding pressure to this equation can also create many dangers, especially if it was not done properly, with proper equipment and a very good understanding of pressurizing vessels, or acidic compounds or chemicals reacting in solution trying to off gas from these reactions which can create dangerous pressures, there are many factors involved also like the thermodynamics, temperature pressure relationship...
Basically it is just Too Dangerous. No reason. Not much added benefit, especially when weighed against the dangers involved…

Warmer solutions are more reactive and will dissolve gold easier or faster, than a slower cold reaction will, a double edged sword here, the warmer solution can also drive chlorine from solution faster or make it harder to keep chlorine in solution long enough to react with the gold, a cold solution is slower but can hold chlorine in solution longer…
We just learn how to balance this double edged sword.

We can also use this knowledge later after the gold is dissolved to rid the solution of excess chlorine when we may have added a bit more than we needed….

In this method we are working on the acid side to dissolve gold, and want to keep on this acid side.

NaCl brine salt solution used as an electrolytic process (with a membrane cell), is used to make chlorine gas at the anode (the chloride from the NaCl being oxidized at the anode to chlorine gas) the sodium ion can pass the membrane to the cathode side, the water H2O is split to H+ and OH-, the membrane blocks the flow of OH- to the anode side, the hydrogen ions reduced at the cathode form H2 gas or hydrogen gas at the cathode, in the cathode chamber the sodium Na+ and OH- form sodium hydroxide or NaOH salt dissolved in solution.

a very similar type of cell using the same brine salt can be used to make sodium hypochlorite, this cell does not use the membrane like above, the chlorine here is disproportionated to form chloride ions and hypochlorite ions, along with the sodium hydroxide being formed in solution.

The basic solution is desirable (sodium hydroxide lowering the pH) helps to keep the hypochlorite in the water solution, remember water can be an acid or a base, keeping the water basic (opposite of acidic) helps to keep the hypochlorite from oxidizing to chlorine gas in with the water solution. Or keeps your bleach bleach and not chlorine gas, and salt water ...

When we acidify this sodium hypochlorite we form chlorine gas, (if the solution is basic we form HOCl) in solution to oxidize (means to take electrons) the gold atoms to gold ions in solution, or saying it another way the chlorine takes electrons from the gold atoms leaving them in solution with the reduced HCl acid and reduced chlorine which form chloride ions in solution (reduced mean these gain electrons) this gives us gold chloride in solution.

In this process (dissolving gold powders or flake) on the acid side, we need to remember, both HCL and the sodium hypochlorite are mostly water, (32% HCl is 68% water) and {5% NaClO (sodium hypochlorite) is 95% water}, this is normally not a problem because there is much NaCl which is formed in the reaction process, from the acid HCl when it is neutralized with the basic hydroxide solution, the water helps to keep the NaCl in solution which forms, and the water involved helps to keep the salt dissolved, or from precipitating (unless we evaporate off this water).

Also we see from this reaction of HCl and the sodium hydroxide we add (involved in the hypochlorite, bleach) uses up a portion of our HCl acid, (and the base hydroxide which is part of the bleach) to make this sodium chloride salt.
With excess HCl acid we can keep on the acidic side, aiding in keeping our gold in solution.

But if we add to much bleach at a time, or too much in general throughout the process, we can get closer and closer to a neutral pH. Or even a neutral salt solution with our dissolved gold (actually making it harder to keep the gold in solution, or out of the precipitating with the NaCl), or we can go over to the basic side of the pH range with our gold chloride solution and where the HOCl becomes our newly formed oxidizer keeping our gold in solution...

___________________________________________________________________________________

This discussion above is different than dissolving gold in a hypochlorite (or basic solution) and adding small portions of HCl acid to dissolve the gold, and HOCl instead of chlorine is the oxidizer...

I did add thoughts of both acidic and basic reactions, (I know for some it may be more confusing but for others it may clear up som confusion).

But in the opposite reaction of dissolving gold in a hypochlorite solution with a little acid addition as discussed for ore, the reactions and chemistry is actually very similar, with very similar principles (almost the same with slight differences) except for the side of the pH scale your working with, and a slight difference in the oxidations states of the chorine, or its compounds, hpochlorite compounds...
Basically both form salts of dissolved gold solution..

It is harder for me to explain the oxidation an reduction of basic solutions, I think backwards enough already, and to look at backwards , backwards, I really get things confused or backwards.
 
A side note to this conversation is that you can use hydrogen peroxide and muriatic acid to dissolve gold foils and powders as well. As with bleach add the peroxide in small doses as need with stirring to get the job done. I prefer using 35% hydrogen peroxide, but any strength should work albeit the weaker concentrations of peroxide are slower to react and create larger volumes of waste solution.

Any mixture of chemicals that produces chlorine can dissolve the gold. You could even theoretically use electricity and salt water or straight HCl.

Steve
 
Thanks Butcher and Steve. That's brilliantly useful background information.

Based on what I've picked up over the past three weeks, with credits also to Pantherlikher, Solar Plasma and more, I'm quietly confident my next batch (hopefully I'll find time this weekend) should give much cleaner foils and less "everything less reactive than copper" cement. (Even though I know it'll all refine the same, I wanna my cleaner foils!)

And I've also got proper filters on the way, rather than, *cough*, paper towel.
This is all just slightly addictive... :)
 
Back
Top