Grelko
Well-known member
Geo said:HCl does react to silver but because silver chloride is insoluble, only the first couple of atoms deep are effected. Once these first few atoms are converted to silver chloride, it prevent any further attack on the silver by the HCl. Any other oxidizer besides nitric acid have no effect on solid silver. When the silver is finely divided, as in cemented silver, a couple of atoms deep may be half the thickness of the particles and you can get a decent amount of silver chloride with just HCl and bleach even though I don't think the bleach has much to do with it.
Thanks for explaining that, I have some silver plated brass and copper items, but I'm still not ready to make a cell for them. I might try HCL on a couple pieces, or small bus bars and see what happens.
What If you added a bubbler, or vibrations "sonication" to the HCL+H2O2, or HCL/CL solution, wouldn't that slowly break off the oxidized layer on the silver and slowly convert the layers beneath it?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silver_chloride ( Upon illumination or heating, silver chloride converts to silver "and chlorine")
I'm constantly thinking about many things at once. :lol: This could make for a fun experiment. Take a flask etc, with HCL/CL or HCL/H2O2, a bubbler, and something silver or silver plated. Heat the solution, or flash a strobe light through it "like taking pictures", which should convert the silver chloride back to silver and chlorine as it's being made by the HCL, then the bubbler should shake off the layer of silver as it's being converted back. You might only need HCL instead of H2O2 or CL. Instead of using a bubbler, you could use sonication "electric toothbrush?"
Then again, if the silver, being converted to silver chloride, and back to silver, would instead re-attach itself to the solid piece of silver, by using the strobe light, then you could technically "cold fusion" silver to another piece of silver. :shock:
Also, according to butcher's post that dealt with kovar, and re-using iron solution instead of disposing of it, ferric chloride should work with silver also, but that may only be for plated items. http://goldrefiningforum.com/~goldrefi/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=60&t=19838