As Geo has stated, I would assume as well that you have dissolved some basemetal, which has cemented back onto the pins, and made them look "bare".
AP is good when it comes to dissolving one single BM and no other, or very few other basemetalss are present - which is the case with goldfingers.
But if there are numerous basemetals in that solution, the acid will attack the one that is easiest to get and then cement it right back onto the most valuable metal. In this case it could be the iron, which is converted into FeCl and then cements onto your gold.
I have recommended before, to use several steps with AP if you have a multi-metal-mix and the predominant basemetal is not copper.
I would make a fresh new AP solution and give it a second go. And maybe even a third with fresh solution. Filter it each time after the reaction ends, check the colors of the filters and eleminate the basemetals one by one (iron, aluminum, copper(II),copper(I)), always with fresh AP solution and test after finishing with SC. After copper(I) you material will be quite free from basemetals and you should only see gold and above in your solution.
Btw: talked to a recycling company that ran 2 Kg of PP for yield testing and the reported around 1g/CPU to me. But as you may have read in the past, this yield varies from 0,3g to even 3g...