Thanks for the report on recovering from ammonia. It was never an issue for me, due to different procedures, but it would have been nice to have had that particular piece of knowledge tucked away in my mind. It makes lots of sense-----that's also one of the procedures for purifying palladium salts.
I also never tried the iron (steel) rod conversion of silver chloride to elemental silver. Because I had an abundance of aluminum on hand, I started using that instead. In retrospect, I can't help but wonder if, perhaps, iron would have been a slightly better choice. My single complaint with using aluminum was the solution after the fact. It was very confusing to see-----looking almost like there was silver in suspension. It took considerable testing over a long period of time before I became comfortable with tossing the solution. I imagine that isn't an issue with iron.
Back to my choice for using aluminum, I did all my conversions, such as they were, in a large handled Pyrex container. It was one I had managed to acquire in trade for a few ingot molds I made for another refiner. He didn't see a use for the container, but I had it earmarked for processing carpets, plus it was perfectly useful for converting silver chloride without fear of breaking, and was quite large in diameter, providing for a nice shallow layer of material that was easily visible. The last time I checked the cost of a replacement, it was well over $300, and that was many years ago, while I was still engaged in refining. To have risked breaking it with a steel rod wouldn't have been something I could have dealt with mentally. That would be my one and only reservation for not changing to iron, even today.
Great report, guys. Now I wish I'd have at least given it a try, so I'd understand the ease by which you can convert the chloride. I am now of the opinion it is easier than aluminum.
As I've said on countless occasions-------anyone that desires to learn refining is missing the boat without owning a copy of Hoke's book. There is so much useful information contained within that it makes it easy for most anyone to go from not having a clue, to being an astute refiner-------and it's all done in simple terms, easy to understand.
Harold