For the record, it was my experience that the darker gold precipitated, the more it was contaminated. When it's fine, as you described, it's entirely possible that contamination is locked in in such a fashion that it won't wash out. That's the point of re-refining.
For years, my process of precipitation (by choice) was to use SO2 from a cylinder. It has huge benefits in that you don't increase volumes, which, to me, was very important, but the best benefit was not adding any substances that had the least bit of a chance of changing the color of my solutions. As a result, when I precipitated my gold, it was absolutely clear to me if it would be relatively pure, or not. When the solution was heavily contaminated, such as when precipitating from filings, which I mentioned earlier, the quality was never acceptable. It was, in fact, so bad, that it was that gold that was melted and used as my added gold when evaporating. That way, it received two more opportunities to be purified.
One other thing I'd like to mention. For many years, I routinely re-refined my gold. It was one of the things that set me apart from my competition, and insured that I never received complaints of casting problems, or brittle gold. What I learned from that experience is that when gold is precipitated from relatively highly concentrated solutions, it comes down what I like to call blonde gold. Instead of the dark bronze color with which most are familiar, it came down a very
light cinnamon color----and on rare occasion, as fine (shiny) crystals. Such gold, when washed, gave up no color. It was relatively safe to assume that it was better than 9995 when it was dissolved, but there is no guarantee that is the case, so everything got re-refined.
It was common to find a
hint of blue in my solutions after a second refining. Proof positive that even the best washing procedures do not remove all contamination.
In order for me to have improved my quality beyond that which I delivered, it would have likely required not using tap water in the process, and maybe even switching to reagent chemicals instead of tech grade. Considering my gold could be melted without flux, and without oxidation, it was clear, at least to me, that my processing was beyond reproach. I exceeded the industry standard on a routine basis, and was content to pursue refining in the manner I chose. Damned few people here will ever be content, always looking for something better.
It's easy to find. It's all in Hoke, where you, too, can learn to process gold of this quality:
Harold