wood4lif,
I will try and answer the best I can, other could give you a better answer.
base metals come in many combinations of metals, they will react differently to acids, some will give distinctive colors to solutions, some do not color a solution at all, some metals like iron can give several colors to solutions depending on concentration what acid or base, pH of solution, temperature and so on, I have seen iron as clear yellow, green orange brown and red, so you see we cannot judge what is in solution by color, as it would fool us, although colors of solution can be an indication of what is in solution, we can test solutions for most any of the metals, with many of the base metals it can be a difficult test, as sometimes we need to remove the metals in a series of tests to determine a certain metal in solution, some tests are more easier and can be used to test for a metal with other metals in solution, some tests we use to determine if our solution contains values and if so what metal is involved, the metals are cations (testing for cations), anions would be the salts of the acids we used like chloride, sulfate, nitrate, there are also tests for these anions.
Plated or gold fill can have many different types of base metals, with costume jewelry you could have any metal involved lead, zinc, bismuth, tin, copper, aluminum, you name it, if they can melt it into an object they probably make jewelry out of it.
I do not know if this helps to answer what you’re looking for but I tried.
No it was not a stupid question, just one that cannot be answered easily, how would I know what your seeing with different colored solutions, I am not there to test it.
Have you been studying Hokes, and doing her experiments, this will give you a clue of how several of these metals react in solution, she also teaches some tests to tell if some of the more important metals are in solution, and for like iron that can look like gold in solution how to test for it to tell if the solution is gold or iron.
Do not get upset if someone does not respond to your post in the time you think they should, many times we read a post and figure someone else can give you a better answer than I could, also the forum has grown so much we cannot always read everything everybody posts, there are subjects I have not got to for months, and people who I enjoy helping that I may not read their post until months after they posted, we are even missing birthdays of some of our good friends until they are older and forgot about their birthday, it is that we do not wish them a happy birthday, we did not know they had it, there is no such thing as a stupid question if someone is working to learn the answer, but not all questions have simple answers, but anyone wanting an answer to a question will find that answer if they keep working to find it, sometimes it may not be the answer we are looking for, and any one searching for an answer is not displaying ignorance.
Chill out, if someone does not give you an answer search for it, seek and ye shall find.
Relax enjoy the forum and the enormous amount of information provided here, you will learn that answer sometimes come slowly to the questions and learning can take time,but if you do not get impatient the answer will reveal itself. as long as you do not give up looking.