First thing is to stop separating all your material. The wider you cast your gold, the more your losses will add up. Use just one filter to collect all your goodies. I like to use only the centre portion of the filter, wherever possible.
You have acted wisely by not adding any peroxide. You should have no gold in solution. Test, to be sure. Always test.
Now, you need to collect all your material. You can either carefully wash all your filters into one container, or you can incinerate them until there is nothing left of them but white ash. Either method has a chance of small losses, depending on how careful you aren't. But don't touch anything with your hands; the oils in your skin make the foils float. Allow it to properly settle, then carefully siphon/decant away the (mostly clean) water.
Then you will have one small container of gold/brown/grey stuff, rather than large jars of scattered stuff.
Add some more fresh HCl to soak in, and you will soon see that you have not yet dissolved all that brown / grey stuff with your gold. Clean gold foils will look like gold, though even they still contain impurities. When you think they're clean foils, another final rinse in clean (tin-free) HCl does not go astray, to get rid of any more problematic tin that might be lurking.