I was cementing silver with copper
even when i put in lot of pipe of copper in 5 gallon bucket.
after i think all silver cement out.
i decant the liquid to another bucket
i add HCL to the liquid,next morning I found out there was silver chloride at the bottom of the bucket.
i was having no idea how that was happen
because I put a fish pump that agitate the liquid and all the liquid touch the copper pipe.
Per the bold print - Because you did not get complete cementation of the all the silver from the silver nitrate
This is likely due to silver nitrate being "trapped" in the silver cement when the cement silver settles in the bottom of the bucket as the silver cements out of the silver nitrate
The silver cement that settles in the bottom of the bucket MUST be stirred up from time to time in order to bring the silver nitrate up & out of the silver cement that is settled in the bottom of the bucket so that the silver nitrate that is trapped in the silver cement can make contact with the copper
because I put a fish pump that agitate the liquid and all the liquid touch the copper pipe.
Though a fish tank air bubbler will keep "some" of the silver cement that is settling in the bucket stirred up it will not keep all of the silver cement that is settling in the bucket stirred up
The bubbler will only stir up some of the silver cement near to the end of the bubbler hose that is bubbling air out the end of the bubbler hose
So - silver that is settling further away from the end of the bubbler hose is still settling in the bucket & trapping silver nitrate in the silver cement as the silver cements out
So - from time to time you still have to "physically" give the silver cement a "good" stirring to bring the silver nitrate that is being trapped in the settling silver cement up & out of that silver cement so that the (trapped) silver nitrate can make contact with the copper
I have always used piece of 1/2 inch or 3/4 inch plastic pipe to do this "physical" stirring with - & you want to do this physical stirring very good - from time to time
As you near the end of the cementing process - where you "think" most of the silver has cemented out you want to start testing to see if in fact all the silver has actually finished cementing out
You want to do this by allowing the cement silver to settle after each time you stir it - then take a small sample of the solution & add a couple drops of HCl - if silver chloride forms the cementing process is not complete & you need to continue the process - which includes more stirring
IMO - when cementing silver you do not need the bubbler - you are better served to just physically stirring the silver cement up from time to time
As a side note; - what is the source of your silver ?
I ask because if there was any lead in your original silver source when you added the HCl you may (or not) have precipitated lead chloride instead of silver chloride
There is a way to test for the difference between silver chloride & lead chloride but that is a whole other post
Kurt