Not much dissolves in low grade Peroxide alone so you must have had some Acid too, true?I got some of that gray goo, i tried to dissolve some barely magnetic connectors, fairly light in weight and with gold plating, the solution barely reacted with oxy water grade peroxide, so, just in case i decided to, eventho still transparent to keep dissolving that batch of magnets in a different container, I done very well because i got A LOT of that gray goo there after, it still sitting there in a separate container this might come in handy.
Anyhow, my point is that it could be something else than tin.
It will dissolve in fresh acid/hp but will re-cement on something after a while.
If something cements out either you have inadvertently dissolved some Gold that cements on the base metals.
Or the Tin itself may be cementing on some of the base metals or the Tin hydrolyses somehow.